“I put my shoes back on”: the Island Bay cottage that won Kate over

Discover

“I put my shoes back on”: the Island Bay cottage that won Kate over

Two friends bought a sea-view Island Bay cottage for $865,000 after a second viewing and an unconditional offer.

Gill South
Last updated: 27 October 2026 | 3 min read
AI

AI summary

Two friends purchased a two-bedroom Island Bay cottage for $865,000. Despite one friend's initial hesitation, a second viewing highlighted the home's appeal, including a great kitchen and coveted sea view.

Their successful purchase was secured with a strong, unconditional offer on the cross-lease property, a strategy recommended by their agent from Tommy's.

They love the village atmosphere and strong community feel of Island Bay. Their advice for other buyers is to build relationships with trusted, local real estate agents.

When friends Kate and Robyn first saw their house in Island Bay’s Rhine Street, Kate wasn’t blown away.

“I walked in and I was just like, this is not for me,” says Kate, a conference and events sales manager.

“I put my shoes back on and just waited outside,” she remembers.

Robyn, an early childhood education head teacher, came out glowing. “I really like this one,” she told Kate.

“I was like, ‘Oh my god, okay,’” says Kate. She puts her first reaction down to feeling out of sorts for a few reasons: the wind, being in a rush, and the access to the house, which is down 38 steps.

They called the selling agent, Chris Robinson from Tommy’s, and asked if they could come back the following week.

They brought a family member along to the second viewing, and Robyn pointed out all the things she liked about the house. This time, Kate saw the appeal.

“We had a good look around and we were like, ‘Right, let’s do it.’”

The house was listed with a “buyer enquiry over” figure in the early $800,000s. As usual for an affordable Island Bay home, there was other interest, but Kate and Robyn’s offer stood out because it had no conditions.

“We were comfortable with all the reports, and Chris said, ‘If you’re happy to go in with no conditions, you’re most likely in with a good chance,’” says Kate.

The friends paid $865,000 for the two-bedroom cottage on a cross lease. There’s only one other owner on the cross lease, and they split the insurance and some other costs.

“I think what we paid was fair. It was over the asking price, but enough for us to get it without a fight, and we’re really happy to be in that house,” says Kate.

It was the end of a fairly long search. The friends had also looked in Brooklyn and Berhampore, and Kate liked a home in Britomart Street in Berhampore very much.

“But we didn’t both love it,” she says. Because they were buying half each, they both had to like the home equally.

The friends had agreed on a list of what they wanted in a home together.

“I wanted a nice kitchen, and ideally two bathrooms. And on Robyn’s list was a view of the ocean, which we got in the end.”

The cottage doesn’t have a second bathroom, but with just the two of them that’s not a big deal, and the kitchen is great, says Kate. They may put a toilet in the laundry in the future.

Every weekend, when they open the doors to air the house, they think, “We’re just so lucky to live here in this house with this view,” says Kate. “And even if we spend all our time at home, that’s fine.”

“The neighbours are great,” she adds. “Every time we see someone new, we say hello.”

They looked all over, but it was always going to be Island Bay, they say.

“I think we like that it’s a bit out of Wellington, so when you’re in Island Bay, you’re not in Wellington, you’re in your own village, which is really nice. It’s quiet and it’s close to the beach,” says Kate, who plans to join the Island Bay Bowling Club soon.

“We just like the community and size of Island Bay. It’s got a nice energy to it. You can just potter about the place.”

They like their Rhine Street community too. They live close to the marae, so they often see people walking there.

Kate’s advice for others hoping to get a foothold in Island Bay is to get to know established local agents they can trust.

“A good professional, well-known agent will be able to point you in the right direction. And I guess, when you’re buying in a community like Island Bay, it’s nice to buy from someone who actually lives in the area. They want to do a good job for you.”

Author

Gill South Gill South
Business and property journalist

Gill is a seasoned business journalist with more than 25 years of experience, specialising in real estate and personal finance. A regular contributor to Trade Me Property, she brings deep insight and clarity to her writing — helping Kiwi make smarter decisions when it comes to buying, selling, or understanding the housing market. Gill also writes for Stuff and the NZ Listener, and her past work includes contributions to the NZ Herald, National Business Review, Callaghan Innovation, and Inman.com. With a sharp editorial eye and a passion for demystifying complex topics, Gill delivers trusted, practical advice for property-minded readers.