Discover

‘Completely irrelevant': The one number a top agent wishes you'd stop obsessing over

Ray White’s Dean Tuffley gives us the no-nonsense advice Kiwi buyers and sellers actually need.

Sam Warlow
AI

AI summary

Ray White agent Dean Tuffley advises sellers to ignore a property's Capital Value (CV), calling it "completely irrelevant." Instead, focus on recent comparable sales to gauge true market worth.

When preparing your home, follow the "$1.50 rule" for renovations—aiming for a $1.50 return on every dollar spent. Prioritise high-impact jobs like water-blasting and fresh paint.

For buyers, Tuffley suggests being upfront with agents to access more opportunities but stresses the importance of completing thorough due diligence.

There's a number a lot of home owners keep an eye on religiously. Maybe on a quiet evening, or after a nosy scroll past the neighbour's place. It's your property's capital value - or CV - and if you've ever used it to gauge what your home is worth, we've got some news.

"The relevancy of a CV is…basically completely irrelevant," says Ray White Mt Eden’s Dean Tuffley. While straight to the point, his message lands: the number you keep checking isn't the number that counts.

We sat down with Dean to get the honest version of how buying and selling actually works right now. No spin, just the advice he gives his own clients.

Let's start with that number you check too often

So if the CV isn't the right metric, what is? Council valuations don’t account for practical reality.  "It doesn't take into account any factors, such as whether it faces north or whether it faces south, what the surrounding properties are like, whether it's had a lot of work done to it that hasn't necessarily needed a consent through council," Dean says.

In short, it's a blunt instrument. What agents actually look at is far more specific: "We look at what the key features are, how it compares to other properties that have sold in the area. And that's how we come up with the potential selling range."

The takeaway for sellers? Don’t anchor your expectations to a CV. Recent comparable sales down your street will likely paint a clearer picture.

If you’re working with a tight budget, focus on high-impact, low-cost jobs first.

The $1.50 rule

Here's the rule worth sticking on the fridge before you spend a cent getting your place to market. "For every dollar that you spend," Dean says, "you want to make sure you're getting at least $1.50 back."

That's the benchmark for every pre-sale job: will it return more than it costs? And there's a companion rule that trips a lot of sellers up.

"One of the biggest mistakes that sellers can tend to make is investing in some areas and not in others," he says. "It's best to either do all of it, or not do any of it." Going all in renovating one area of the house could highlight how dated another area is, and may not move the needle as much as you think.

If you’re working with a tight budget, focus on high-impact, low-cost jobs first.

"It has to be those simple little one-percenters that make the biggest difference," Dean says.

His hit list includes things easily knocked off in a weekend:

  • Freshly water-blasting concrete areas and decks (especially south-facing ones).
  • Touching up tired paintwork.
  • Ensuring carpets and curtains are clean and presented at their best.

 

None of it is glamorous, but all of it is noticed.

If Dean could give sellers just one tip, it'd be to give yourself more leeway. "Have plenty of time up your sleeve," he says.

More time means better access to staging, a smarter run at the calendar, and room to "avoid the public holidays, avoid the school holidays, and ensure that you give yourself your best possible chance."

Effective home staging can make a big difference.

Buyers, this one's for you

If you're on the hunt for a home, the best piece of advice might surprise you:  Don’t play it too cool.

"There are benefits to working with the local agent and letting them know you are interested, rather than playing hard to get." Stay coy and you lose out - "playing hard to get means you're not going to get the most information about the property," from auction dates being brought forward to offers landing on the table.

Being upfront also gets you access. Engage proactively with an agent and you’ll hear about upcoming listings before they hit the market, as well as off-market opportunities.

Just don't let enthusiasm replace the homework. "Make sure you're doing the due diligence," he adds. Get a lawyer, hire a trusted builder to inspect the property, and ask plenty of questions. "A good relationship with the person you're buying through is really important."

So, can you still get top dollar?

"Getting a premium price in today's market is absolutely possible, and we are doing it time and time again," Dean says.

"You've got to create the competition."  That means a well-presented, beautifully staged home marketed by an agent with a strong database and real reach. Do the one-percenters, give yourself enough time, and the results will follow.

"It can be done."

Author

Sam Warlow Sam Warlow

Sam is Trade Me's Video Content Specialist who believes the most interesting thing about any home is the person living in it. 

Across property and motors, Sam creates content that helps Kiwi feel confident, curious, and inspired about the places they live and the decisions they make.