Feature article

Divine church hall conversion with hidden wine cellar looking for new custodian

The church hall was built in 1928 and renovated in the early 2000s.

Gill South
Last updated: 27 February 2026 | 4 min read
AI

AI summary

Discover a unique 1928 church hall conversion in Wadestown, Wellington. This spacious 219m² home blends historic charm with modern living, featuring soaring ceilings, stained glass windows, and a hidden wine cellar.

Fully renovated and seismically strengthened by developer Brian Cameron, the property includes three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a mezzanine, and a double garage. It offers an ideal alternative to apartment living, providing ample space and privacy without body corporate fees, just a short walk from the CBD.

Amy Russell enjoys the fact her Wadestown home looks like an average house from the street and then, as people enter, they’re often amazed by the soaring ceilings, stained glass windows and sheer sense of space.

The house is a former church hall which was converted into an airy, pleasant residence in the early 2000s - with a few little surprises along the way.

“When my husband and I were doing our wish list of all the things we wanted in a house, before we even started looking, I did a little Visio diagram of a house with all the things that we listed, and one of them was a secret wine cellar behind a concealed bookcase, down a spiral staircase. And we nearly got that,” says Russell.

As the former parish hall for St Luke’s Anglican church next door, the building has served as the venue for concerts, Scouts, and ballet recitals, plus as a polling booth during past elections.

The space has high ceilings and a Juliet balcony.

Big windows for a heavenly view.

Built in 1928 the property has character in spades. There’s the hoped-for wine cellar, exposed brick walls, a Juliet balcony, a piano nook upstairs on the mezzanine, and beautiful lead-light windows, which is one of Russell’s favourite things about the house.

“It has that beautiful lead light window, with the Juliet window facing it and I think just the height and the loft of the building, and all the light gives it that sense of being a sacred space,” she says.

There are some other touches that Russell loves, including the cupboard doors upstairs which have rattan panelling - reminiscent of a church confessional screen.

“I think that’s such a clever design – and it’s something I would look for anywhere I was moving to, because it means there’s always airflow, but you don’t see anything inside the cupboards and I find them beautiful as well to look at,” she says.

The home is light and sunny.

The home has three bedrooms and two bathrooms. Downstairs is an office, as well as the expansive living spaces. The large kitchen, which has been the scene of many family Christmas dinners, opens onto a covered patio.

The home was strengthened and updated in 2002-2003 by developer Brian Cameron, who put in steel girders which run the entire length of the building, through the downstairs apartment and down into the ground.

Russell remembers Cameron, now retired, coming to the house to see how it fared in the 2016 Kaikōura quake.

“He was delighted to see that basically everything was absolutely fine,” she says.

While this is a spacious home of 219m² which has a double garage, Russell believes it will appeal to Wellington buyers who are looking for apartment living but want to avoid a body corporate and a lack of space.

“It’s a home that easily expands to accommodate a family of four with the mezzanine upstairs, but it doesn’t feel too big if there are just two of you,” she says.

“A lot of people need an apartment lifestyle but don’t want to live in an apartment in the city, and it’s not easy to find something as private as this is. It does share a floor with the downstairs flat, but you’d never know.”

The home has a spacious kitchen, perfect for entertaining.

The hidden wine cellar.

The two units have very good sound proofing, says Russell, - even with people living downstairs who have had newborn babies - Russell has never heard them.

Wadestown is a popular Wellington suburb which is likely to appeal to people working in the CBD. Russell, an economist at Treasury, walks to work the scenic way every day - half an hour there and half an hour back.

As for the local community, it’s very friendly, she says, and has some excellent local amenities including a library, takeaway outlets, and cafés nearby.

“We have a Pitt Street WhatsApp group and people are constantly offering each other produce overflow from their gardens or letting someone know they’ve left their garage open, or sharing a photo they’ve taken of a stray dog or a stray cat. It’s a really lovely feel,” she says.

Tommy’s agent Alice O’Styke is marketing 2/32 Pitt Street, Wadestown. The property has an RV of $1.350 million and is for sale by tender which closes on March 12.

One of the bedrooms, featuring the rattan door.

The exterior of the old church hall.

Most Properties, More Choice
Explore endless possibilities on NZ's favourite property app.
Download on iOS Download on Android

Author

Gill South Gill South
Business and property journalist

Gill is a seasoned business journalist with more than 25 years of experience, specialising in real estate and personal finance. A regular contributor to Trade Me Property, she brings deep insight and clarity to her writing — helping Kiwi make smarter decisions when it comes to buying, selling, or understanding the housing market. Gill also writes for Stuff and the NZ Listener, and her past work includes contributions to the NZ Herald, National Business Review, Callaghan Innovation, and Inman.com. With a sharp editorial eye and a passion for demystifying complex topics, Gill delivers trusted, practical advice for property-minded readers.