Feature article
Heritage stone farmhouse in Mt Eden ‘brimming with potential’
A historic Mt Eden farmhouse ready for a new chapter.

AI summary
A rare historic stone farmhouse in Mt Eden, known as Coldicutt House, is on the market for the first time in 40 years. Dating to the 1840s, this Historic Place Category 2 property is a unique remnant of Auckland's early farming history, built from local basalt.
The three-bedroom home sits on a 1262m² site and offers exciting potential for restoration. It retains original character alongside a modernised kitchen and bathrooms, and is being auctioned by Bayleys Ponsonby.
This stunning stone house, which dates back to the 1840s, has been listed publicly for the first time in 40 years, now that the owners have relocated to the UK.
Currently empty, the Georgian-style “farmhouse” is just waiting for the next guardian to take it over, refresh the property and bring it back to life again.
The home, which was once called Coldicutt House, has a Historic Place Category 2 listing. It is described by Heritage New Zealand as a “rare and important remnant linked with the creation of small-scale farms on the outskirts of Auckland”.
Originally known as Coldicutt House, the house was built by English settlers William and Sarah Coldicutt who developed a smallholding here - at the time the location was considered to be on the outskirts of the city. Photo: Bayleys
The house was built in the Georgian style, with a strong sense of symmetry. Photo: Bayleys
While the exact year of construction is unsure, it is believed the house could have been built as long ago as 1844, for English settlers William and Sarah Coldicutt, who established a small holding here that year.
The house is built from basalt and is one of just a few such houses in the city to survive, and it’s an “even rarer example of a stone farmhouse on its original site”. Basalt is a volcanic rock found in abundance in Mt Eden - it frequently features on dry walls, such as the one on the street front of this property.
At the rear the house opens up to a vast area with fruit trees and overgrown topiary gardens - the site is 1262m². Photo: Bayleys
Listing agent Robyn Clark of Bayleys Ponsonby describes the property in her listing as “brimming with charm, character and exciting potential”. The exterior still has all its original character, from the hipped roof and dormer windows to the front portico and shutters.
And the setting, although overgrown, also retains its magic. The three-bedroom house sits on a 1262m² site (zoned for two houses), in a fairy tale setting, with many mature trees, original statuary and topiary.
Inside, the 19th-century character is much in evidence, from the polished native timber floorboards to the original painted sarking in many rooms, which include two living areas and a dining room. Mullioned windows and raked ceilings remain in the two bedrooms on the upper level. And even the door at the bottom of the staircase appears original.
There’s an easy flow between living areas on the ground floor. Photo: Bayleys
Traditional panel-door cabinetry and modern appliances feature in the kitchen. Photo: Bayleys
The kitchen and two bathrooms were replaced a few years ago for modern convenience, but are in keeping with the period feel - traditional panel doors feature on the cabinetry and there is a large butler’s sink.
NZ Heritagenotes: “Internally, it incorporated four main downstairs rooms, an underlying cellar, and two additional rooms in the attic. Larger than some other stone farmhouses of the period, the dwelling may reflect the relative prosperity of Manuka Grove Farm, which by the mid-1860s had expanded to three times its original size.”
The property, at 753 Mt Eden Rd, Mt Eden, Auckland, has an RV of $1.425 million and will be auctioned on April 8, 2026.
Upstairs, there are two bedrooms and a second bathroom - they retain their original character. Photo: Bayleys
Although ripe for a renovation, the house is perfectly habitable. Photo: Bayleys
Cotality puts the median property value in Mt Eden at $2,073,304. Other recent sales of heritage homes in the suburb include 27 Ngauruhoe St, which sold for $3.015m earlier this month; and 122 Grange Rd, which sold last month for $2.75m.
Property market update: Cotality NZ's latest Mapping the Market analysis, which provides suburb-level property insights across the country, notes that the New Zealand housing market is stabilising at a suburb level.
The figures show 56% of suburbs recorded stable or rising house values in the three months to March, up from 44% previously, signalling a gradual improvement despite overall national growth remaining subdued.
A shady veranda runs the length of the house at the rear. Photo: Bayleys
There’s plenty of magic in the property, with hidden gems to be discovered. Photo: Bayleys
Regional resilience, patchy city outcomes: More affordable regional areas with strong rural economies (such as Southland, Otago, West Coast) are leading gains, while city markets show mixed results with both modest growth and continued declines at suburb level.
Among standalone houses, Herne Bay in Auckland remains the country’s most expensive suburb, with a median house value of around $2.99 million, followed by Saint Marys Bay at $2.86 million.
Outlook points to modest, uneven growth: Improved affordability, steadier mortgage rates and easing listings should support gradual value growth through 2026, though high supply (especially townhouses) and buyer caution mean a strong rebound is unlikely.
Author
Discover More

From armoury to Kaipara home: the Kaiwaka house with a spy story
A former armoury, clad in steel and lined with mataī, is now a three-bedroom home above the Kaipara Harbour.

The 6 best building inspectors in Auckland (according to reviews)
These are the guys you want looking at a property before you buy
Search
Other articles you might like



.jpeg)






.jpeg?fit=max&format=webp&quality=85)


