Discover

Historic church and presbytery for sale: Choose one or both

From their elevated position, the former St Patrick’s Church and Catholic presbytery have a commanding presence.

Colleen Hawkes
Last updated: 15 January 2026 | 4 min read
AI

AI summary

A historic church and presbytery in Lawrence are for sale, available together or separately. The four-bedroom Edwardian presbytery is fully renovated with modern central heating while preserving its heritage charm.

The adjacent St Patrick’s Church, an 1892 design by architect Francis Petre, is a blank canvas with original stained glass and timbers, offering huge potential.

Located on the Clutha Gold Cycle Trail, these properties are ideal as a unique home, accommodation business, or special-purpose venue.

Here’s the thing about Lawrence - like Dunedin, heritage properties were built to keep out the cold, and they were built to last - triple brick walls are commonplace, along with stone and concrete.

But there’s another interesting fact: Pretty much every old church in the wee town (and there were lots) has been deconsecrated, sold off and given a new lease of life. And the former St Patrick’s Church may be the last.

It sits alongside the former twin-gabled Catholic presbytery, and both properties have come to market this month and will be sold separately. They are both owned by Alexandra and Thomas Ehret, but while the four-bedroom presbytery has always been a home, the church is a blank canvas.

Originally on one title, the property was subdivided by current owners, Alexandra and Thomas Ehret. The presbytery and church can be bought separately.

The church, designed by Christchurch Basilica architect Francis (Frank) Petre, was opened in 1892 and has a Historic Places Category 2 heritage listing. The Edwardian presbytery was built in 1903.

Both properties were on a single title (and still owned by the Catholic church) when the Ehrets bought in 2022 - they have since subdivided. And it was word of mouth that brought them back from Germany to make the purchase. The couple had rented the presbytery between 2008 and 2010 and loved living here, but went back to Germany to live.

The handcarved timber stairs lead to the four bedrooms on the second storey.

“When we were renting we always said if it ever comes on the market, we’ll try and buy it,” Alex Ehret says. “And then when we were in Germany we heard from someone that it was for sale. There was a Dutch auction and a lot of interest, but we were able to get it.”

There were many things about the presbytery that influenced their decision: “We loved the feel of the place, the triple brick walls- the way it’s built - and the history. We come from Europe, and Europeans love history and old houses, and since New Zealand is such a young county, you don’t often find unique properties like this.”

They also love the fact that “back in the day” church buildings were built to face the sun and often built in an elevated position, as these two were.

The owners have renovated the presbytery extensively, in keeping with the heritage character.

The couple still use the original coal range (centre left), saying they enjoy the warmth of the fire, and like to use it for cooking. They have kept the original rimu cabinetry.

Ehret says they originally had plans for the church, but have given the presbytery all their attention over the past four years, refurbishing extensively. They have renovated in keeping with the Edwardian era, and they have kept most of the original features, including the old coal range.

“There is a radiator in the kitchen, but most of the time we prefer to use the range, because then we can use it for cooking at the same time. And it’s a different warmth.”

They have also kept the existing kitchen cabinetry: “It’s solid rimu and we thought ‘where are you going to get a kitchen like that these days?’. We gave it another coat of paint, and it’s perfect. It fits in with the style of the house.”

Every room has its own distinctive character.

This bedroom has a traditional Sanderson hunting wallpaper. There are wide views from all the bedrooms.

Heating in winter has also been sorted. The couple imported a Stiebel-Eltron central heating system from Germany, with Italian radiators in every room. “We just put it on 20deg and the entire house is warm and cosy.”

The couple also imported many beautiful wallpapers, including Sanderson designs - every room has its own character, which makes it well suited to an Airbnb operation.

The former church has all its original features intact, including native timbers and beautiful stained glass windows imported from Germany back in the 1800s. It is believed they were destined for a church in Australia, but ended up in Lawrence.

The church has a grand entry, and would be an ideal function centre.

‘So much potential’

Alex Ehret says the church has huge potential for many different uses - it could even be connected with the presbytery as a function centre. “We had the idea of perhaps putting a museum in there there. But you could put little holiday apartments in there.”

Other former churches in the region have been converted into holiday homes and Airbnb properties, and there is always a demand for accommodation in Lawrence. In the town’s heyday of the goldrush era, the population soared to many thousands, and while today it numbers in the hundreds, there is a continual demand for traveller accommodation.

Listing agent Lucy Hibbert-Foy of Bayleys describes Lawrence as “the gateway to central Otago”. The town is directly on the Clutha Gold Cycle Trail, which brings in a demand for accommodation. She believes the church could also be an ideal venue for concerts, weddings, performances, or even a boutique cinema.

These windows were believed to have been destined for a church in Australia “back in the day”, but were diverted to St Patricks Church in Lawrence.

Handcrafted detailing is evident everywhere.

When it comes to price, one thing is certain in this town - you get value for money. The 290m² presbytery, at 12 Colonsay St, Lawrence sits on 1036m² and is listed with enquiries invited “over $889,000”. For the 290m² church on 997m², enquiries are invited over $459,000.

Property market update: Cotality reports an increased interest in property in Southland. The company says while regional performance varied in 2025, some areas reaching new peaks: Southland’s districts hit record median values in December, and several provincial centres, including New Plymouth and Queenstown) saw increases.

In contrast, Auckland and Wellington remained weak, with declines from peak values exceeding 20% in most sub-markets.

2026 outlook is cautiously optimistic: The report forecasts a potential 5% rise in property values, supported by lower mortgage rates and economic recovery. However, regulatory changes (LVRs, DTIs, capital gains tax debates) and household mortgage decisions will be key factors to watch, especially in an election year.

Most Properties, More Choice
Explore endless possibilities on NZ's favourite property app.
Download on iOS Download on Android

Author

Colleen Hawkes Colleen Hawkes
Stuff
Journalist specialising in property, housing, architecture and design stories.