News Next article

Item not as described? Here's what to do

Bought something that's not what the listing promised? Here's how to sort it out with the seller, and when we can help.

By Trust & Safety team 5 October 2026

When an item doesn't match the listing, you've got options.

Wrong colour, unmentioned damage, or not what the photos promised. It's a frustrating situation, but you've got options, including cover under our Buyer Protection policy. Here's what to do if your item turns up not as described. 

Stop using the item. Don’t get it repaired

As soon as you notice something's wrong, put the item aside. It's fine to use it briefly to show the problem, like switching it on to film a fault, but avoid using it beyond that, and don't try to fix it or take it to a repairer. If the item needs to be returned, it should be in the same condition as when you first spotted the issue. Using or repairing it could change that, and make it harder to show what went wrong.

Check it's genuinely not as described

Before you get in touch with anyone, pull up your purchase confirmation and read the listing again. Sometimes what looks like a mismatch is covered in the fine print, like a photo showing wear, a skipped size chart, or a disclaimer you missed. If the item is genuinely different from what was described, or it's turned out to be faulty, that's a not-as-described situation, and the steps below apply to you.

If you've simply changed your mind about the item, this process won't help. You’ll need to contact the seller about your return options instead.

Contact the seller

This is the step that matters most. Sellers on Trade Me want to protect their feedback, and will likely sort out a genuine problem as soon as they know about it. That might mean a refund, a repair, a replacement, or something in between.

A few things that help this conversation go smoothly:

  • Be specific about what doesn't match the listing.
  • Attach photos or videos. It helps the seller understand quickly, and it's useful if you need to escalate later.
  • Give them a fair amount of time to respond before taking things further.

If you can't resolve it together

Sometimes a seller won't respond, or you can't reach an agreement. That's what our dispute resolution process is for. Our Disputes team steps in to help both sides find a resolution. 

Ready to file?

Head to our help article for the full process, what you'll need to include, and our response timeframes.

File a dispute report

Buyer Protection could cover you

If you paid with Ping or Afterpay, an item that's genuinely not as described could be covered under Buyer Protection, meaning you could get a refund of up to $5,000.

When you file a dispute report, we'll check your eligibility for Buyer Protection as part of that process, so there's nothing extra you need to do. Purchases made by cash or bank transfer aren't covered, which is one more reason to pay through Trade Me where you can.

Full eligibility details are in our Buyer Protection policy.

Need to take it further?

Most not-as-described situations get sorted out by having a conversation with the seller. But if a dispute report doesn't resolve things, we may point you toward the Disputes Tribunal, an independent body that can hear the case and issue a binding decision. 

For anything else, like cancelled trades, refunds, or general trade issues, our Trade issue FAQ has quick answers to the most common questions.

Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash.

Author

Trust & Safety team Trust & Safety team

We’re the team working behind the scenes to keep Trade Me the safest place for Kiwi to buy and sell. From spotting scammers to helping you navigate a sticky dispute, we’ve got your back.